Pilot

Additional

Language
Java
Version
0.2.1 (Oct 12, 2015)
Created
Oct 1, 2015
Updated
Dec 8, 2021 (Retired)
Owner
Dorian Cussen (doridori)
Contributors
Making GitHub Delicious. (waffle-iron)
Santiago Castro (bryant1410)
Dorian Cussen (doridori)
3
Activity
Badge
Generate
Download
Source code

This project is now DEPRECATED as times have moved on and I have personally started using a Redux / FSM mix.

See Android Architecture: Runtime Centric Thinking

Pilot

Pilot is a way to model the Application State in a familiar (android.* decoupled) Stack structure, and provides hooks for View based UI Rendering to take place. This facilitates:

  • Single Activity applications
  • A (passive) thin-View based architecture
  • android.*-less app navigation (i.e. Controller -> Controller)
  • An abstract backstack
  • Stack-based data scoping
  • Use of any kind of MV* approach

Why

  • Cleaner, decoupled code
  • Avoiding Fragments is desired for many reasons, not limited to flexibility of how the backstack is used
  • Flexibity of what lives in the backstack enables easy data-scoping for session / screen data as it lives in the stack rather than being passed around or statically based
  • Easy testing
  • As facilitates MV* approaches this means not having to think about asynchronous operations in your UI code (i.e. you can ignore Loaders, RxLifecycle handling or whatever other approach being used to work around the android lifecycle)

Components

Application State

Type SRP
StateStack A Stack of StatStackFrame objects
StateStackFrame Frame that lives in a StateStack. May represent a Screen or scoped-data.
@HiddenStateFrame Annotation which removes a StateStackFrame from all StackStack change observer callbacks

Rendering (Android)

Type SRP
StateStackRenderer Holds the StateFrameSetRenderer collection that is queried upon StateStackFrame change events
StateFrameSetRenderer Interface for an object that can compose a UI for a given set of StateFrame classes
StateStackActivityAdapter Bridge between the hosting Activities lifecycle events and a StateStack instance
StateStackFrameBackedFrameLayout Convenience FrameLayout base for BackedByFrame backed views

Seperating Application State from UI Rendering

It can be beneficial to separate the Applications State from the rendering of the UI as really these are separate concerns.

Application State is generally concerned with:

  • What is the user currently doing?
  • What was the user previously doing that can be returned to?
  • What happens if the user decides to do something else?
  • What data is associated with what the user is currently doing?
  • What operations are associated with what the user is currently doing?

Rendering is generally concerned with:

  • How can the user visualise what they are currently doing?
  • How does the user return to what they were previously doing?
  • How does the user signify they want to do something else?

The primary win when decoupling in this way is by seperating reponsilbilities testing and refactoring becomes much easier. A secondary advantage is that the Android rendering could be replaced with a terminal, or other type of client.

One design principle is that the Stack should not change regardless of the screen size or rotation. Any master/detail changes (or other size related rendering logic) should sit in the Rendering layer, which in Pilot is abstracted by the StateFrameSetRenderer.

Another design priciple is that the Application State should be pure java, to facilitate JVM testing.

Supplementary Aims

To make usage of this project as flexible as possible, the following decisions have been made:

  • Not to tie any consumers to a specific controller type. The reason for this is that all projects have their own approaches in terms of what a Presenter/Controller should be and this is really an orthogonal concern to how the lifecycle and navigation between these controllers is handled. You may prefer to use MVP (Passive View, Supervising Controller, Presentation Model), MVVM or some other variant, this should not impact how the controller layer is managed.

  • Not to require any 3rd party dependencies (e.g. Dagger or RxJava). These (and other) libraries can be used with Pilot but are not essential.

View only?

At present Pilot is for use primarily with View-only UI's. While this seems restrictive I feel adding Fragment support at this point would distract from the main aim of this project. Fragments are great as they are a wrapper for a sub-section of the UI, which have lifecycle callback support and backstack etc. I find when these concepts are pulled out (as they are in Pilot) UI components suddenly become simpler and less bothered about these concepts, and therefore humble View becomes the obvious choice for how to render an applications state, as represented by Pilot.

You may end up with a single-Activity application with nothing but simple Views!

Not the first

Of course I am not the first to think in the way. The guys at Square were talking about very similar things (simple Views and abstract backstack management) years ago - this is a slightly different approach for how to realise those concepts.

Nor am I the last! Conductor is a very similar library which has appeared with the same concepts (and better documentation). Good to see others are thinking along the same lines. I will continue with Pilot however as sure we will have slightly differnt take on things.

EDIT: Moxy and Triad and Magellan and Flowless and ThirtyInch are similar recent repos

Doc Contents

The rest of this README is split across a few doc files:

Usage

repositories {
    jcenter()
}

dependencies {
    compile 'com.kodroid:pilot:1.0.2'
}

Proguard

-keepclassmembers class * extends com.kodroid.pilot.lib.android.frameBacking.PilotFrameLayout{
 public <init>(android.content.Context);
}

-keepclassmembers class * extends com.kodroid.pilot.lib.stack.PilotFrame{
 public <init>(com.kodroid.pilot.lib.stack.Args);
}

WIP

This is a WIP and is currently in development. Some of the supplementary docs also need updating as the project is still undergoing some conceptual refactoring. I am welcome to any input via the Issues page to guide its development. This library is not in use in production yet.

License

Copyright 2015 Dorian Cussen

Licensed under the Apache License, Version 2.0 (the "License");
you may not use this file except in compliance with the License.
You may obtain a copy of the License at

   http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0

Unless required by applicable law or agreed to in writing, software
distributed under the License is distributed on an "AS IS" BASIS,
WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY KIND, either express or implied.
See the License for the specific language governing permissions and
limitations under the License.